Matchbook

How to date a vintage matchbook cover, and what the clues can and cannot prove

Striker position, ZIP codes, phone exchanges, manufacturer marks and union labels: seven clues for dating a matchbook, and the limits of each one.

Quick answer: You rarely get a date from one clue. You get a window, and every clue you add narrows it. A striker on the front means the cover is from 1978 or earlier. A five digit ZIP code means 1963 or later, and a ZIP code with four extra digits means 1983 or later. A phone number written with a letter exchange, like CHelsea 2-5034, points to the 1960s or earlier, though the cutoff varied by city. The manufacturer’s mark, once identified, gives you the years that company operated. Overlap the windows and write down the range, not a single guess.

Matchbook collectors are called phillumenists, and the hobby’s own reference material admits the limits of dating. The most useful thing to know before you start is which clues give you a hard boundary and which only give you a hint. This guide sorts them, with the sources, so you can tell a firm fact from a collector’s rule of thumb.

The short history, and where the sources disagree

Dating a cover starts with knowing when matchbooks existed at all, and the early history is less settled than most articles admit.

What the sources agree on: a Pennsylvania patent attorney and inventor named Joshua Pusey received U.S. patent 483,166 for a “Flexible Match” on September 27, 1892, and the Hagley Museum and Library credits it as the first patent for matchbook covers. Wikipedia’s matchbook entry adds that weeks later Charles Bowman of Lebanon, Pennsylvania, patented the version with the striking surface on the outside, closer to what we know today, and that Pusey challenged it without success.

Where they disagree:

  • When Diamond Match bought Pusey’s rights. Hagley gives 1894, with a $4,000 payment and a consulting role. MatchPro’s hobby history also says 1894. Wikipedia puts the sale in 1896.
  • The first advertising covers. Wikipedia dates the Mendelson Opera Company’s hand-lettered covers to 1893 or 1894. MatchPro dates them to 1896 and notes they were blank covers written on by hand, so they are not collectible in the usual sense.
  • The first big printed order. MatchPro says Pabst Beer ordered 10 million printed matchbooks in 1902 and calls it the real turning point for the hobby. Other accounts put a Pabst order earlier. I could not reconcile these from the sources I read.

For dating a cover in your hands, the practical takeaway is simple. Printed advertising matchbooks start around the turn of the twentieth century, not in 1892. A cover older than about 1900 is very unlikely to be what you have, and a claim that one is should come with strong evidence.

Clue 1: where the striker is

This is the single most useful clue for the later decades. MatchPro’s “How Old” guide says the last front-strikers appeared in 1978, so a cover with the striker on the front is pre-1979.

That is a one-way boundary. It tells you the latest the cover can be. It does not tell you the earliest, and a back-striker cover can be from almost any decade, so it narrows nothing on its own.

Clue 2: ZIP codes

Look for a postal code in the printed address. The ZIP Code system started on July 1, 1963, according to ZIP Codes.com’s history, and the extended ZIP+4 format, with a hyphen and four more digits, followed in 1983 (see the Wikipedia ZIP Code entry).

  • A five digit ZIP means the print date is 1963 or later.
  • A nine digit ZIP means 1983 or later.
  • An address with no ZIP proves little, because printers left them off long after 1963.

Add a caution: covers were often printed in large runs and reused for years, and some printers kept old artwork and added a ZIP later. Treat a ZIP as a floor on the print date, not an exact date.

Clue 3: the phone number

Older numbers began with a letter exchange name, such as “CHelsea 2-5034”. The telephone industry started phasing these out with a field test of all-number calling in Wichita Falls, Texas, on January 19, 1958, and the first large conversion came in March 1960, as described in Wikipedia’s all-number calling article. The change then spread over the 1960s and the timing depended on the city. Sources I read put the switch in Youngstown, Ohio, in the mid-1960s and the end of exchange names in Toronto in 1966.

So a letter exchange suggests a cover from the early 1960s or before, and an all-number phone suggests the late 1950s or later. The overlap between those is wide, and the rule works best when you know the city. Look up when that city converted before you lean on this clue.

A bare area code is a weaker hint. Area codes were introduced under AT&T’s 1947 numbering plan, but local calls did not need one, so covers often print a local number without it.

Clue 4: the manufacturer’s mark

Most covers carry a small printed mark or a company name, often near the bottom of the back or inside the flap. Collectors call these manumarks. The clue works in two steps: identify the maker, then look up when the maker operated.

MatchPro says that for most manufacturers the years of operation are known, and it points to a “MM Dating Guide” that lists known date ranges for specific manumarks, describing it as the most comprehensive ever done. That is the reference to use for exact ranges. I could not read it in full while researching this article, so I am not copying ranges from memory. Use the guide itself.

The same MatchPro guide lists striker width, cover length and footers as age indicators. It gives no years for them in the part I could read. That matches how collectors use them: as supporting evidence once you have a window from the other clues, not as a way to find one. Small “midget” covers are another feature collectors track as a category.

Clue 6: union labels

Printers’ union labels appear on many American covers, and they feel like a strong dating tool. The evidence says to be careful. A catalog record at the Heinz History Center for a cover with an Allied Printing Trades Council label gives a date range of 1932 to 1990, which is much too wide to help alone. Combine the label with the phone, ZIP and striker clues, and use the label to confirm a U.S. print job, not to pick a year.

Clue 7: events and tied-in dates

Some covers date themselves. Convention covers for the Rathkamp Matchcover Society, which describes itself as the oldest matchcover collecting organization, carry a year, and libraries catalog 1959 and 1960 examples. The same goes for covers printed for an anniversary, a grand opening or a dated event. Wikipedia notes one famous example: matchbooks printed for a 1927 dinner for Charles Lindbergh, of which only about 13 are known, and one sold for $6,000 in 2015.

A worked example

Here is how the clues stack, using an invented cover.

Clue on the cover What it tells you
Striker on the front 1978 or earlier
Five digit ZIP code 1963 or later
Phone as “PLaza 3-1234” Likely before the city’s all-number switch, probably the 1960s or earlier
Manufacturer mark Look up the maker’s years of operation

Put them together. The ZIP says 1963 or later, the striker says 1978 or earlier, and the letter exchange pulls the window toward the early to mid 1960s. A reasonable catalog note is “c. 1963 to late 1960s, check manufacturer.” Notice that the note gives a range and names the missing check. A single year would claim more than the evidence supports.

What not to trust

  • Price and condition. A clean cover is not an old one.
  • The first date you see. A copyright or “established” date on a cover is often the business’s founding year, not the print year.
  • A single clue. Every clue above can be wrong alone. They are useful in combination.
  • Auction listings. A seller’s “circa” date is an estimate, and so is a museum cataloger’s. The Heinz range above is a reminder of how wide those can be.

Write the range down

Once you have a window, record it with the reasoning, so you can revise it when you learn more. Our guide to what to record for every matchbook covers the full checklist. A good entry notes the venue, city, striker position, any ZIP or phone clue, the manumark, and your estimated range with the clues that support it.

Where Matchbook fits

Matchbook is an iPhone app for collectors to archive matchbooks with front and back photos, the venue, city, country, era and category, and personal notes and condition details. You can browse, search and filter the whole collection. Everything is stored locally on your iPhone, and the app does not need an account. It does not date a cover for you. You make that call from the clues above, and the app is where you keep the answer and your reasoning. See Matchbook.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell how old a matchbook is?

Use several clues together: striker position (front means 1978 or earlier), ZIP code (1963 or later, nine digit 1983 or later), phone exchange style, the manufacturer’s mark, and physical features. Each gives a boundary, and the overlap is your date range.

When were matchbooks invented?

The first matchbook cover patent was granted to Joshua Pusey on September 27, 1892, and a competing design with the striker on the outside was patented by Charles Bowman weeks later. Mass advertising use came after Diamond Match acquired the rights in the 1890s.

Is a matchbook with the striker on the front older?

It is pre-1979, because the last front-strikers appeared in 1978. That is a latest-possible date, not proof that the cover is very old.

Do ZIP codes help date a matchbook?

Yes, as a floor. A five digit ZIP means 1963 or later, and a ZIP+4 means 1983 or later. A cover without a ZIP could still be later than 1963.

What is phillumeny?

Phillumeny is the hobby of collecting matchbooks, matchboxes and match labels. Collectors are called phillumenists. The Rathkamp Matchcover Society, a matchcover specialist club, dates to the early 1940s.

Are old matchbooks valuable?

Most are inexpensive. Value comes from rarity, subject and condition. At least one historic cover, from the 1927 Lindbergh dinner, has sold for $6,000, but a typical restaurant cover from the 1960s is not one of them.

More from Set In Stone

For the cataloging side, read what to record for every matchbook. For another hobby where the record matters as much as the object, see what to record in an embroidery project journal, with Embroidery Journal.

Sources and further reading

Matchbook

Archive each matchbook with front and back photos, the place, the era and your notes, all stored privately on your iPhone.

Get it on the App Store